I feel like writing at once about something that has delighted me. In talking with Thomas Sergeant Perry1 last night we fell to discussing your work, and to my delight I found him a great and unequivocal admirer of your work. I was pleased beyond measure, for Mr. Perry's opinion on your work is more valuable to me than that of any man in America—with one exception. Mr. Perry is a man of vast learning. He is a historian of literature. He knows the development of all Western literature, he is just finishing a large volume—very radical—on the Greek literature, he has written on German and English literature. His criticisms are based not on personal feelings but upon principles—he looks at any man from the comparative standpoint. He is the leader of that school of thought with us here. So you see this has value—this opinion of his. He has been abroad for some years studying and now is writing on various historical lines. Mr. Howells2 and he were two of my most honored friends.
Correspondent:
Hamlin Garland
(1860–1940) was an American novelist and autobiographer, known especially
for his works about the hardships of farm life in the American West. For his
relationship to Whitman, see Thomas K. Dean, "Garland, Hamlin," Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia, ed. J.R. LeMaster and
Donald D. Kummings (New York: Garland Publishing, 1998). On April 19, 1888, Garland, who was a friend of
Kennedy's, wrote to the poet for the first time. He was giving a series of
lectures entitled "Literature of Democracy" in which he was "trying to analyze
certain tendencies of American life somewhat in accordance with the principles
you have taught." Garland did not share Kennedy's gloom about Whitman's
reception: "I am often astonished at finding so many friends and sympathizers in
your work and Cause. In my teaching and lecturing I find no difficulty in
getting Converts to the new doctrine and find your poems mainly irresistible in
effect. True they do not always agree that they are
'poems' though acknowledge their power and beauty. I do not care what they call
them (I say to them) and receive their allegiance just the same."